Routers beyond Connectivity

Re-Imagining Wi-Fi Router Interfaces for Intuitive Set-up & Control
Project Summary

User Research & Product Design to achieve intuitive processes for seamless Wi-Fi setup and management.

My Role
Product Design Consultant

Leading and implementing End-To-End project research, design & conceptualization for client. Collaborating with Engineering & Development teams to translate design into a shippable product.

Timeline

6 Months - August, 2022

Disclaimer

This project case study uses the 'Cisco' brand name for illustrative purposes only and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Cisco Systems, Inc. The use of 'Cisco' is solely for educational and demonstrative purposes. A placeholder brand name has been employed to protect the confidentiality of the original client. Due to an existing partial Non-Disclosure Agreement, certain project details have been omitted.

Project Result

The project resulted in the design & development of a new Wi-Fi router which has an interactive display, accompanied by a mobile application.

See in detail
Project Kick-Off
"We want to get into the smart-home space but don't want to invest in developing a completely new device. I know its a difficult ask, but we're doing it for business diversification."
Identifying the Problem

What kind of a device to target?

What?

The initial task for this project was to identify an area of work to validate the client's findings from preliminary research.

How?

By mapping out various consumer product categories, a clear gap emerged showing what devices have a balanced proportion of display and control mechanisms.

Wi-Fi / Mesh Devices

These devices had a very low degree of interaction with humans, with basic displays.

Smart Home Devices

These devices had the most ideal proportion of display and control interfaces.

Wi-Fi routers & Mesh devices being an outlier indicate that there is an opportunity of intervention.
Understanding the Market

Market Research to validate the opportunity of intervention.

What?

Identifying Market Size, Growth Trends and Forecasts for Wi-Fi Routers/ISP Devices.

How?

Conducting Secondary research by analyzing available market reports and published research.

Key Insights driving Growth
Smart Homes & IoT Expansion

Rising demand in Wi-Fi equipment which supports Smart Home devices and its ecosystems.

Telecom Industry Collabs

Telecom companies are increasingly bundling services with equipment manufacturers for customer retention.

E-Learning and Remote Work

Online Learning & Remote Work is motivating buyers towards reliable Wi-Fi Equipment and services.

Statistical Insights
$ 29.92
Billion

The expected global market size of the Wireless Router market by the year 2033.

$8.58
Billion

The expected global market size of the Home use/domestic use Wireless equipment by the year 2033.

India, China
& Japan

The greatest regional market growth globally considering the increased internet penetration & rise of smart home IoT devices.

A few challenges were identified, even though statistics show a strong industry.
#1

Inconsistent high-speed internet performance in homes.

#2

Addressing security concerns like phishing and data breaches.

#3

Compatibility with diverse devices and user-friendly setup features.

These are real world challenges, but they are inherently infrastructure & service level issues. They cant be solved by introducing a new product into the market.
Introduce user research to discover deeper insights.
User Research

Identifying the user's interaction patterns with Wi-Fi routers.

How?

Using a discovery based approach, interview studies were conducted which helped decipher a range of insights highlighting issues mainly in the Set-up process for WiFi routers and services.

Why?

Secondary research informed a deeper investigation of the 'Setup' process. Practically every home-owner or possibly even a renter would be involved in the 'Setup' process.

The Research Process
01

Identified 30 participants who had experience interacting with Wi-Fi devices for either their homes or offices.

02

Conducted 45 minute interviews with 26 participants to understand their experiences related to independent setup of Wi-Fi services.

03

Interviews informed a round of Ergonomic Analysis with 18 participants to understand their interaction patterns with a generic Wi-Fi router.

04

Analysis of data to identify user flows and product requirements.

Key Findings: User Interviews

What did the User Interview activities reveal about the user's behavior during the setup process?

Creating multiple usernames and passwords increased the confusion during the setup process.

Un-optimized and non-responsive web platforms enabled the setup process, leading to high degrees of frustration and requiring extra effort from the user's end.

Key Findings: Ergonomic Analysis

What did the Ergonomic Analysis activities reveal about the user's interaction patterns?

Labels and info-graphics are usually not legible as they are tiny when viewed from a normal distance of more than 25cm.

The LED indicators on a router are indistinguishable from each other given the relative scale of each in context to the viewer.

Most individuals place their routers at a height of 6 ft to 8 ft in their spaces 'assuming' it gives them better range and connectivity throughout the house.

User Stories: A Few Highlights

What did the User Interviews & Ergonomic Analysis activities reveal about the user's interaction patterns?

Pravin Shah

32 years old

Home & Office Routers

As a work from home person, everyone uses Wi-Fi at home, even my kids. I need seamless connectivity for both personal and work devices and separate virtual networks. I'm frustrated by cluttered living spaces, connection issues, and confusing labels and lights on my current router.

Sneha Patel

19 years old

Portable Wi-Fi Dongle

The Wi-Fi dongle should block ads, provides fast internet, and track my data usage. I'm frustrated by internet trackers, lengthy activation processes, and inconsistent signal strength in different areas.

Jasvir Singh

52 years old

Smart Home Wi-Fi & Mesh

I have a lot of smart home devices so I need a simple internet setup, clear error messages, and VPN integration. I'm frustrated by complicated and boring on-boarding processes that hinder my seamless smart home experience.

User Interviews helped reveal some much needed opportunities!
#1

Enhance Parental controls & Security controls.

#2

Introduce independent service setup procedures.

#3

Real-time network analytics & dashboards for homes.

Users face the most friction during the Set-up process of a new wireless service. That is when they interact with the device the most too!
Concluding Research: Defining the product requirements

Collaborating with the client to define a set of product requirements which satisfy the research findings as well as business goals for the client.

#1

A standalone router with a clean & modern aesthetic, enabling the device to blend in well with modern day households/living spaces.

#2

Integrating a display in the router, leveraging IoT, for quick consumption of information relating to wireless service usage.

#3

A mobile companion application to control the router's various states, as well as customize the information on the display.

Design

Ideating & Iterating for simpler Wi-Fi set-up process.

What?

Design oriented creative activities used to conceptualize the product idea with interaction design, informed through previous research.

How?

Initiating by developing a 'Product Brief' and 'Design Theme-board' to inform subsequent design activities such as 3D form development, Interaction design and UI-UX of the proposed product.

The Design Process
01

Explored product features informed through user stories identified during user research.

02

Identified a theme-board by collecting a few design inspirations reflecting an aesthetic preferred by the identified user base.

03

Defined technical dimensions in conjunction with visual and physical ergonomics.

04

Designing & Conceptualizing the device display simultaneously with the mobile application.

Feature Development

Brainstorming a range of features which try to solve the current issues the users face. These features are in context to the complete ecosystem and not limited to the device.

Mapping the need for a feature, simultaneously identifying its common existence among competitors through an 'Effort:Impact' assessment.
Collaborating with various engineering teams to estimate the feasibility of the feature within given time-frame and budget.
3D Development

Sketching and ideating the 3D form of the device, transitioning into the design engineering phase in collaboration with the engineering team.

Ideating the form of the device with proportions informed through User Research and a themeboard.
Product Brief

To design a Wi-Fi router for a 'smart, modern home', controllable through a companion mobile application having a display to increase its utility in a domestic scenario.

Collaborating with the engineering team to define technical dimensions for the device.
Interface Development

Sketching and ideating the interfaces for the ecosystem. Collaborating with the development team for final development and production.

Ideation and iteration cycles to design the device interface and mobile app interface to incorporate finalized features.
Developing high fidelity interfaces for the system.
Solution & System

Using the 'Cisco Wireless' Ecosystem.

The Final Feature-Set

The project posed a challenge in deciphering what exactly to work upon initially, however it resulted in a range of significant features to be added to the conventional features a Wi-Fi router offers. A few have been explained below.

01
On-Boarding into the System

A simple 2-step account creation process, utilizing back-end validation for increased security.

02
Scan to Set-Up

One singular QR code scan to set-up the device, detecting hardware credentials and pairing the device to the mobile app.

03
Home Deck

A one-screen interface including all the features implemented for the system. Interface designed considering scalability and future addition of newer features.

04
Device Modes

A range of modes were designed to add informational value to the product when in functional spaces in a home environment.

Privacy Mode
Network Data Mode
Guest Mode
Reflections

Concluding the project and handing off data & assets.

Leading projects where one is an independent design professional working with teams of engineers is a true challenge in communication. This was such a project.

From research up until the design phase, independence in decision making was a luxury provided by the client. However, once the design and development phase initiated, a lot of constraints popped up due to costs, timelines and availability of resources. Tackling these constraints was a huge improvisational and learning aspect for this project. Collaboration proved to be the best solution to conclude the project!

Like what you see?
Let's Connect! →